Chocolate Chip Peanut Pie from my cookbook, Something Sweet, is indulgent and delicious, but also really easy to make!
I’ve been teasing you guys for so long, first with a cookbook announcement, then a behind-the-scenes post, then I unveiled the cover and showed you some photos, but now, finally I’m ready to share a sample recipe from my cookbook! Make sure to scroll down past the recipe, because I’m also giving away a signed copy of the book!
I’m especially excited to share this recipe because it’s one of the first that I came up with for my cookbook, and it’s so amazing, so indulgent, so delicious – yet ridiculously easy. If you, like me, are a lover of all things peanut butter and chocolate, this is the stuff your dreams are made of. Just trust me when I tell you that this is about to become your new family favorite!
Don’t be left out! Pre-order your copy of Something Sweet now! Amazon | ArtScroll (use coupon code OTC for free shipping + a signed copy!)
- ¾ cup dark corn syrup
- ¾ cup creamy peanut butter
- ¾ cup sugar
- 2 eggs
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 cup roasted salted peanuts, coarsely chopped
- 1 cup chocolate chips
- 1 ready-made graham cracker crust, preferably chocolate
- chopped peanuts, optional, for garnish
- chocolate sauce, optional, for garnish
- whipped cream, optional, for garnish
- Preheat oven to 350°F.
- In a small bowl, whisk together corn syrup, peanut butter, sugar, eggs, and vanilla until smooth.
- Add peanuts and chocolate chips; stir until evenly distributed.
- Pour mixture into graham cracker crust.
- Bake for 45 minutes. Filling may be slightly soft in the center, but it will firm up as it cools.
- Serve at room temperature. Garnish with chopped peanuts, chocolate sauce, and whipped cream, if desired.
Note You might think this would be even more delicious when served warm, but trust me — it’s best served at room temperature, when you’ll get the optimal texture and maximum flavor. This dessert is very rich, so don’t be tempted to cut big slices.
Plan Ahead This pie freezes well in an airtight container.
Want to see how this page will look in the cookbook? Click here to download a PDF of this page! Make sure to notice the clean layout, how easy to read it is, and the special feature on every page: PLAN AHEAD! You got it! Every recipe indicates if it can be frozen, and offers any special instructions, if needed.
One last thing before we get to the giveaway! So many of you have asked about a launch party, where you can meet me, get your book signed, taste some samples, and ask me your baking questions. Well, good news is coming! Stay tuned for an announcement…
Giveaway Details!
Giveaway is over! Congrats to the winner, Shoshana!
Want to win a signed copy of my cookbook? Of course you do! Here’s how:
IMPORTANT: Each entry requires its own comment. If you do both entries, make sure to leave two comments. If you do both entries in one comment it will only be counted once. You can do either or both of the following:
Entry #1 – Leave a comment on this post telling me which is your favorite SWEET recipe from Overtime Cook
Entry #2 – Follow @overtimecook on Instagram and leave a separate comment on this post telling me that you did. Note: if you already follow me, that’s fine. Just leave a comment letting me know that!
Giveaway ends at midnight (eastern time) on Tuesday, August 25th, 2015. A valid email address must be provided. Winner will be contacted via email and will have 48 hours to respond. Prize can be shipped within the continental US. Giveaway is sponsored by ArtScroll.
Thank you guys so much for reading, and for all of the support! Now go buy yourselves a book (you deserve it!) and then buy a copy for everyone you care about – they deserve it too! But first: Make. This. Pie. You need it! -Miriam
Never miss a new recipe! Follow me for all the updates on:
Facebook| Instagram | Twitter | Pinterest
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links, which means that a small percentage of every purchase made through that link goes to help support this blog.
peach crumb muffins.
I follow you on instagram!
Favorite recipe: best chocolate chip cookies!
I follow you on instagram.
Love the cherry apple crumble !
I have made your lemon cheesecake mousse many many times, sometimes in huge quantities as part of a sheva brachos dessert. It is light and delicious.
I follow you on Facebook and Instagram .
I already follow you on instagram.
Peanut butter cookies… no surprise there…..
zebra cake
Neapolitan zebra cheesecake
I follow you on instagram
I follow you on Instagram!
I like the smores bundt cake
a proud instagram follower 🙂
I follow you on instagram
My favorite is the oatmeal butterscotch cookie. but i do love them all!
Chocolate chunk cookies (in ami). Follow on instagram
Definitely the peanut butter cheesecake bundt cake!!!
Already following you on instagram!!
Follow on Instagram
not your bubby’s honey cookies! DELISH!!!
Hot Chocolate cake! YUMMMM!!
following on instagram!
and even though i’m an instagram newbie, i do follow you!
Love your zebra cake!
Snickerdoodles are the best!
I follow you on Instagram 🙂
and I follow on instagram 🙂
Yum!! Lemon mousse cups!
Marge free choc chip cookies!!!
Already following on Instagram
I love the chocolate chip cookies without margarine But with oil!
No oil Chocolate chip cookies
Follow on insta
No Marg chocolate chip cookies
I follow you on Instagram
Lemon mousseeeeeeeee, sorry, was drooling
youR chocolate chip cookies are out of this world!
Totally your Instagram stalker!
We have lots of Overtime Cook favorites! The most recent one is the Stone Fruit Cornmeal Cake. Contragulations on this huge milestone! Can’t wait to see your book in real life.
Honestly, it’s hard to pick as I am a huge fan of your recipes- but if I have to go by what I make most often- it would be your Skinny Iced Vanilla Latte. Yum!
Triple Chocolate Oreo Chunk Cookies! Cant wait to read the cookbook…
Just started following you on Instagram 🙂
Cookie dough pie
I follow you on Instagram.
I follow you on Twitter.
I love your coffee mousse trifle recipe!
I follow you on instagram! Love your photography!
the coffee crinkle cookies!
The Cappuccino Cheese Muffins sound amazing!
I’m following on IG (@amymaddux)
Lemon mousse cups
Smores Bundt cake!
I follow you on instagram
I live cappuccino mousse cups!
Chocolate chip cookies!
I already follow you on instagram!
S’mores pie
I follow you on onstagram
I love the baked Nutella donuts and skinny mocha frappe!
I love Smores bundt cake and the sweet potato cupcakes with maple frosting!
Gooey Caramel Pie – YUM!!!!!!!!!!!!
Follow you on Instagram
I love all the oil based cookies!
I follow on instagram
Chocolate chip peanut butter oatmeal cookies were huge hit
S’mores pie (won best tasting at my office’s annual baking contest!)
Chocolate Chip Peanut Pie
Snickerdoodles! But everything always looks amazing….
Insta follower….
Your marshmallow icing was amazing…. made it awhile ago
So many to choose just one! But with Elul beginning, I’m about to head back to the Not your Bubby’s Honey cookies 🙂
Gooey Caramel Pie!
I follow you on instagram
I follow you on Instagram 🙂
You’re Best Ever Chocolate Chip Cookies Without Margarine or Butter is my “go-to” sweet recipe of yours. Love it!
Following you on Instagram
Love your donut cookies. Looked and taste amazing !
I follow you on instagram
The no marg CC cookies are my go-to almost weekly!!!
hot gooey caramel pie
I love your no margarine chocolate chip cookies.
Love love your lemon mousse make it all the time
Following you on instagram 🙂
Zebra cake!!!
My favorite sweet recipe is the no margarine crickel cookies
All about the gooey caramel pie!
Following on instragram
Lemon mousse cups!
I follow you!
S’mores Pie is my favorite!!!
I follow you on Instagram
I love the cookie dough fudge pie!!
My favorite recipe from your site is definitely the chocolate chip cookies!
Thank you!
Love gooey caramel pie!
I follow you on instagram!
Fried Ice Cream! Made it last year for Chanukah instead of latkes 🙂
Looks amazing! Cookie dough pie is my fav!
Best Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies are so good and gets raves reviews!!!!!!
I already follow you on Instagram!!!!
Love the lemon mousse cups!
Follow on Instagram
Hot gooey caramel pie!!’ Best!!
Pecan pie with mini fudge bites on top
Following on Instagram
Lemon mousse cups
I started following you on Instagram
love the pecan tarts!
I follow you on instagram
Already following on Instagram
Your cinnamon buns!! (Although I hear there’s an easier dough that you got from your Grandma waiting for me in the cookbook!)
I made 16 pans of them for my son’s Bar Mitzvah and they were GONE!!
Love love the apple cherry layered crumb cake (kugel) !
Following on instagram!
Your triple chocolate chunk cookies are awesome!
I already follow on Instagram @alexandrarobertson7
Margarine free chocolate chip cookies
I follow you on instagram
I follow you on Insta!
S’mores pie….and anything with chocolate!
I love the smores bundt cake!
I already follow you on Instagram
i follow you on instagram!
The hot gooey caramel pie. hands down
Love the margarine free chocolate chip cookies!!
I follow you on instagram!
gooey caramel pie is delicious!
Chewy Chocolate chunk cookies from Ami
I Follow you on Instagram
I love your triple chunk oreo cookies!!
Caramel pie!
Your margarine free chocolate chip cookies are the best!
zebra bundt cake for sure!! looks pretty and tastes heavenly!!! can’t wait to try out all your new recipes!
cookie dough pie
I follow you on Instagram and looking forward for cookbook!
Lemon mousse
Following on Instagram
The choc chip cookies without margarine are the best ever!
I live your gooey caramel pie. Yuummmm
I follow you on instagram 🙂
i follow you on Instagram!
I love your pumpkin spice crinkles
Love the no margarine choc chip cookies
Lemon cheesecake mousse!! Yum. Your recipes are amazing!
I follow you on instagram.
Hi Miriam,
I already follow on instagram!
Chocolate pomegranate bundt cake
No doubt, Smore’s Bundt Cake!!
This time of year your honey cookies with lemon icing 🙂
Gooey caramel pie
I love the hot gooey caramel pie! Mazel tov on the cookbook coming out!
I stalk you on instagram 😉
I love your chocolate chip cookies!! 🙂
I follow on Instagram 🙂
I like the apple kugel recipe!!
Definitely your chocolate chip cookies!
I follow you on Instagram
Your peanut butter chocolate chip cookies!!
love the gooey caramel pie!
I follow you on instagram
No marg choc chip cookies!
I follow you on instagram
Chanukah felt cookies!! I also have a list of others that I want to try out!
I already follow you on Instagram
Peanut Butter Bundt Cake with Chocolate Cheesecake Filling – um, yum!
Blueberry Crumb muffins are out of this world!
Love your lemon cheesecake mouse cups!!
Following on Insta 🙂
coffee crinkle cookies are heaven!
I follow you on Instagram, made so
Many recipes from you already!!
Cookie dough pie….mmmmmm
So hard to pick just one, but I love the chewy chocolate chocolate chunk cookies!!! Thanks for all your delicious recipes!!!
My favorite is the butternut squash orzo. I know its not a typical sweet recipe but it is definitely sweet and I make it weekly!
I like your Pesach Chocolate Blintz Cake. I could just eat the blintzes plain. I hope I win a free copy. I never serve dessert, now my kids will have a chance at somethings sweet for the end of the meal.
Cookie dough pie!
Just started following you on Instagram!
gooey caramel pie
Chocolate chip cookies with corn starch
follow on instagram
I follow your on instagram!
Favorite recipe is your chocolate chip cookie fudge pie!
Chocolate chip cookies with no margarine…underbaked!!
My family’s favorite is the gooey caramel pie!
Chewy Chocolate Chocolate Chunk Cookies 🙂
I follow you on istagram
Gooey caramel pie! !
Love the lemon mousse cups
Smores bunt cake!!
I follow you on instagram.. Best feed!
Already an obsessive fan on Instagram!
Peanut Butter Bundt Cake with Chocolate Cheesecake Filling
Gooey caramel pie
hard to pic a favorite. Everything I have made has had rave reviews but I do amake your no margarine chocolate chip cookies and chocolate chunk cookies and they are a big hit. Especially when combined.
I’m following you!!
Fav sweet recipe = Hot Gooey Caramel Pie every time!
Hubby and I love your smores pie!!
Chocolate chip cookies!!
Following you on instagram! Would love to win your cookbook
love the coffee crinkly cookies
already follow u on instagram
Peanut butter cookies!
I follow you on instagram!
My guests LOVED the caramel gooey gooey pie 🙂
Loved the cookie recipes that had no margarine. Coffee crinkle cookies were a big hit.
I love soooo many of your recipes but my favorite sweet ones your cinnamon buns and your red velvet cheesecake cookies….AMAZING!
The Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies
I follow you on instagram @keke_sparkles
Love the gooey caramel pie
The cherry Apple layer crumb kugel is a staple in our house. My kids literally ask for it every week!
Best Ever chocolate chip cookies without margarine or butter.
I follow you on Instagram
We love your gooey caramel pie!! My husband goes crazy for it and will eat the leftovers cold with his coffee 🙂
Hot gooey Caramel pie and cookie dough fudge pie to hard to decide between the two?
Hot Gooey Caramel Pie is my fave!!
I follow you on Instagram IG:risselrussell
Chocolate peanut butter surprise cookies 🙂
I follow you on instagram
peanut butter cookies
Gooey caramel pie!! And oatmeal cookies!
Chocolate chip cookies!
I love your Pumpkin Spice Crinkle Cookies! I’m ready to Pumpkin Spice All The Things!
I follow Overtime Cook on Instagram: laurimw86.
my kids love the snickerdoodles. My husband loves the peanut utter cookies! Thanks for all your delicious recipes
margarine free choc chip cookies
I follow you on instagram
Best Ever Chocolate Chip Cookies Without Margarine or Butter –
Just made them, they’ll be my new chocolate chip cookie staple!
Wow, I have to pick just one??? That’s hard! I LOVE the chewy chocolate chocolate chunk cookies and the best ever chocolate chip cookies without margarine, but I guess number one would be the cookie dough fudge pie!
Homemade Cinnamon Buns with Cream Cheese Frosting! As good as it sounds…and smells…and TASTES!!
The Zebra Cake looks great!
I follow you on Instagram as cezovski9
I ❤️ The hot gooey Carmel pie i make it almost ever you tov
I love the coffee crinkle cookies I make them every Sunday when I’m bored
I follow @overtime cook on instagram
Following you on Instagram
stone fruit cornmeal cake!
I already follow you on Instagram.
I made the lemon mousse cups in milchig and parve. Delicous
Just found the coffee crinkles recipe. I think they’ll be my new favorite cookies.
Following on insta
peanut butter cookie cups
I already follow u on instagram can’t wait to get the cookbook!
I already follow u on instgram!! cant wait to get cookbook!
S’mores cake the best
just made your chocolate chip peanut butter pie….it is great
Hard to choose just one! But the cin buns with cream cheese frosting is by far my favorite!
And of course I also follow you on Instagram! 🙂
I made your chocolate cupcakes w/ chocolate glaze earlier this summer for a friend’s shower… they were a hit!
PB Blossoms
Love your iced coffees!
I really like the chocolate oreo cookies- so easy to make and such a yummy cookie!
Love the pumpkin cookies!!
I love the pumpkin cookies
Lemon mousse cups
Follow you on instagram
I love zebra bundt cake
Following you on Instagram already
Coffee crinkle cookies
i like the Healthy Double Chocolate Chip Muffins 🙂
Love the caramel pie!
I follow on instagram!
Mini double chocolate trifle – yum!
i usually stick with the savory recipes, but I just made your zebra cake and it was delcious and pretty!
cookie dough fudge pie
So many great dessert recipes to choose from, but the Chocolate chip cookies without margarine saved me so I’ll have to go with them. Can’t wait to get the cookbook!!!
chocolate chip cookies without butter/margarine
The Apple Cherry Layered Crumb Cake (Kugel)
Instagram follower 🙂
Lemon mousse cups! I follow on FB and Instagram!
I follow you on instagram. Love your recipes!
Already subscribed. Love the personal interaction with your fans ☺☺☺
zebra cheesecake.
coffee crinkle cookies, there easy to make and everyone loves them. thank you.
I just made the pie. Baked it like you said. The top is quite well done and the inside is very gooey, didn’t seen to firm up. Any suggestions?
I love the gooey caramel pie
Smores Pie!
I already follow you on Instagram 🙂
Just started following you on instagram!!
My favorite used to be the hot gooey caramel pie but this looks like it has the potential to beat it!
I followed you on Instagram
Jrlcofsb
The oatmeal peanut butter chocolate chip cookies!
Reverse choc chip cookies!!
peanut butter choco chip cookies and peanut butter surprise cookies!!
I follow you 🙂
Gooey caramel pie!! And coffee cheese cake mousse
I follow you on Instagram
not your bubbys honey cookies, the BEST cookie ever!!!
I follow you in instagram!
Coffee crinkle cookies
Coffee crinkle cookies
The healthy double chocolate muffins. Still and always <3 Need more healthy delicious sweets please!
your caramel pie !
following on instagram
Chocolate Chip Peanut Pie sounds yum! I could sure use the cookbook… Mine are on the other side of the world. Don’t do Instagram…
Cookie pie
Hot goey Caramel pie is my fav go to dessert!!!!!!
Following on Instagram!
I loveeee the smores bunt cake!!!!
I follow you on Instagram 🙂
I follow you on Instagram
I have to many recipes I like from overtime cook. Most often made is probably the margarine free chocolate chip cookies, but can’t say that that’s for sure our favorite
I now follow you on instagram!
Your Grape Upside Down Cake is my favorite sweet Overtime Cook recipe. I love baking with fruit, and it’s nice to have a cake recipe that uses grapes. Such a pretty cake, too!
I really enjoy your recipe for Chocolate Peanut Butter Surprise Cookies!!
the margarine free cookies are my favorite..but a close second is the coffee crinkle cookies
I follow you on Instagram
You know, I always loved your recipe for red velvet cookies!
I follow you on instagram!
Pecan brownie pies …get tons raves
Cinnamon Buns!!
I already follow you on instagram!
I love this recipe chocolate chip peanut pie. I made it for shabbos and everyone loved it!!
We love the triple chocolate chunk cookies!!
Hot Gooey Caramel Pie! I just served one for Shabbos and have another one in the freezer for R”H!
love the chocolate peanut butter crunch cookies
Cinnamon Buns with Cream Cheese Frosting!!! 🙂
Following on Instagram….
Hot Gooey Caramel Pie, & anything with caramel, for that matter 😉
I have to make it but the hot and gooey caramel pie just sounds amazing!
I have yet to make it but the hot and gooey caramel pie just sounds amazing!
I make your chocolate chip cookies (and am given too much credit for their amazingness- thanks for letting me :p)
My favorite recipe on overtime cook is the no margirine chocolate chip cookies
I follow you on instagram
Peach crumb muffins
gooey caramel pie
Hot gooey caramel pie
Your Streusel Swirled Butterscotch Bundt Cake is out of this world!
Hmmmm…. Close call between the chocolate chip cookies without margarine and the PB oatmeal cookies!!! Would love a cookbook w even more desserts from u!!!!
Already follow u on Instagram
your blog is amazing! My favorite is your double chocolate chip muffins- just I make them with real sugar and they are divine 🙂
peach crumb muffins its the best
I must try the smores cheesecake!
Caramel pie. Thanks for the giveaway.
I follow on instagram.
I follow you on Instagram and am so impressed with your continued success!!
love the easy no oil choc chip cookies
I follow you on instagram
Caramel pie!
Congratulations!! Can i say everything is my favorite..STARTING with Hot Chocolate Cake and lemon mousse. Thanks
Best ever chocolate chip cookies!
I follow you on instagram!
Coffee crinkle cookies are yum! And everything u share:)
Hot gooey caramel pie
Your protein cookies
Your protein cookies
My favorite sweet recipe is your Hot Gooey Caramel Pie! Always a favorite around my houre! So easy to make and always finished!!
I already follow you!
Love all of your recipes, especially the ones that include peanut butter and chocolate together!
Following on Instagram
Chocolate chip cookies
5 stars but it doesn’t want to work.
snicker doodles
I follow you on instagram.. u have the best recipes
I have to pick one?!?!?! Honey cookies def. A winner!
I don’t have dark corn syrup, will light work?
Sure